In this article
The Center for Creative Leadership describes listening as a coaching skill. The conversation design below is an editorial exercise for everyday management, rather than a substitute for specialist coaching or formal employee support.
Active listening begins by agreeing the purpose
Ask what would be useful before choosing your response. A colleague who needs a decision may become frustrated by an extended coaching exercise. Someone who wants to develop a solution may feel dismissed by immediate instructions.
Try: “Would you like me to help you think it through, give a view, or make a decision with you?” The answer can change during the discussion.
If there is an immediate safety or compliance problem, act through the proper process. Do not withhold a necessary instruction in the name of helping someone find their own answer.
Set a realistic time boundary. “I can give this fifteen focused minutes now” is more useful than pretending to listen while another urgent meeting is starting.
Ask for the problem before asking for solutions
Invite a concrete account: “What happened, and what do you need to be different?” Let the speaker finish the first explanation.
Then identify the question they are trying to resolve. “We have a supplier problem” could mean a late delivery, an unclear contract, an unhappy stakeholder or a decision nobody owns. Each needs a different conversation.
Useful prompts include:
- What do you know directly?
- What are you assuming?
- Which part can you influence?
- What has already been tried?
- What decision is needed now?
Use one question at a time. A rapid sequence can feel like cross-examination and leaves the speaker deciding which part to answer.
Notice your own urge to demonstrate competence. Your first workable idea may not be the best idea, particularly when the employee has information you lack.
Reflect the meaning, then invite correction
A useful reflection is a testable summary. “You have two requests for the same capacity, and neither requester knows about the other. Have I understood?”
Avoid simply repeating the last few words. The point is to establish a shared picture, not to perform a technique.
Be cautious with emotional labels. “You sound frustrated; is that right?” allows correction. “You are defensive” assigns a judgement and usually narrows the discussion.
Do not assume silence means understanding. The colleague may be working out an answer, translating into another language or deciding whether a concern is safe to raise. Offer time without interpreting the pause for them.
A hypothetical coaching conversation
Imagine Leo, a project coordinator, says: “The sales team keeps changing the delivery date. I cannot keep up.”
The manager could immediately tell sales to stop. Instead, she asks which dates changed, who authorised them and what customers have been promised.
Leo explains that requests arrive through separate messages. There is no shared place to see the current commitment. The problem is partly a coordination process, rather than simply an unreasonable colleague.
The manager asks Leo to propose two ways to make changes visible. He suggests a shared request log and a weekly approval window. Together they examine which urgent changes would still need an exception.
Leo leaves owning a small process proposal. The manager owns arranging access to the relevant sales lead. Neither has been asked to solve the other person’s part through goodwill alone.
This example is hypothetical. It illustrates a reasoning path, not evidence that a particular conversation will produce a measurable result.
Help the employee compare options
Once the problem is clear, ask what alternatives exist and how they would choose. Encourage a second option before settling on the first acceptable one.
A practical comparison can use four questions: What would this solve? What would remain? Who needs to agree? What is the smallest reversible test?
Offer your view when it contributes something necessary. Make the transition explicit: “I have a concern about the approval step. May I add it?” Coaching does not require pretending you have no expertise.
If the employee asks for help beyond their authority, respond directly. They should not have to discover a prohibited decision by failing an invisible test.
Close with ownership and support
Ask the colleague to state the next action in their own words. Agree what they own, what you will provide and when the issue should return.
Write down only what is needed for the work, with appropriate confidentiality. A coaching conversation should not become an unnecessary record of personal disclosures.
At the follow-up, ask what happened and what changed in their understanding. Avoid evaluating only whether they followed your preferred solution.
For related practice, read Peak Belt’s clear communication guide and leadership skills guide, or explore TrueNorth.
Know when the conversation needs another route
A colleague may raise a concern that needs a formal report, specialist support or a decision beyond your authority. Explain that boundary plainly. Listening carefully does not authorise you to act as a therapist, investigator or legal adviser. Help identify the appropriate route and avoid promising confidentiality you cannot maintain.
In your next suitable conversation, delay advice long enough to verify the actual problem. That small change makes the employee’s reasoning visible before yours takes over.
AI-assisted researched guidance from PeakBelt. Hypothetical examples are labelled in the text. See our editorial approach.